AI, Human Judgment, and the Fight for a Fair Trial | 11-17-26
Liberty RoundTable PodcastNovember 17, 20260:24:5011.37 MB

AI, Human Judgment, and the Fight for a Fair Trial | 11-17-26

AI can automate tasks, but can it replace human purpose, relationships, and judgment? Sam Bushman and James Edwards debate the future of work, the risks of relying on automated systems, and why increasingly capable bots may still need human direction.

The conversation opens with a lighthearted discussion about Meta and broadcast software before turning to campaign spending and funding independent media. Bushman argues that AI will create opportunities alongside job losses, while Edwards questions how workers will adapt as automation advances.

The hosts also discuss the Lindsay Clancy case, debating hung juries, retrials, double jeopardy, and media pressure. Throughout the episode, they return to a central question: just because technology can do something, should people hand over the responsibility?

Linked Timestamps

00:00 Liberty Round Table introduction

00:39 Should Sam sue Meta? A lighthearted naming dispute

02:35 New broadcasting software and the network’s production capabilities

04:49 Campaign spending versus investment in independent media

08:04 AI voice applications and the debate over bots taking control

08:51 Software failures, cybersecurity, and the limits of automation

11:56 Will AI eliminate jobs or create new opportunities?

14:35 Why human relationships and decisions still matter

16:11 Lindsay Clancy case discussion: Hung juries and retrial questions

18:37 Would people actually want bots doing everything?

21:01 The hosts debate jury unanimity and double jeopardy

23:38 Fully informed juries and the court of public opinion

Call to Action

What would you trust AI to handle, and what should always remain a human responsibility? Share your thoughts on jobs, automation, and jury decisions in the comments. Subscribe to Liberty Round Table and share this episode with someone thinking about how AI could change their work and everyday life.

[00:00:04] Broadcasting live from atop the Rocky Mountains, the crossroads of the West. You are listening to the Liberty Roundtable Radio Talk Show. Happy to have you along, my fellow Americans. The question is, should I or should I not? Lindsey Clancy in the news. We'll get to that. James Edwards with me, thepoliticalsessible.org.

[00:00:30] Every Saturday night live award-winning broadcast or on demand at your fingertips anytime you like. Thepoliticalsessible.org. In the should I or should I not column, should I sue Meta, James? Let me tell you why, then you can decide. Meta launches an app called Direct. It's a standalone messaging app, they say, for Instagram. TechCrunch with the news. Direct is launching first in Turkey and Thailand.

[00:01:00] And can be used with or without an Instagram account. So it's basically a messaging app. Called Direct. Well, I don't know if you know, but I've owned a broadcast software called ACDC. Or Audio Compass Direct Connect. For more than a decade. If I have an app that's in the communications world called Audio Compass Direct Connect. And then they have a product called Direct. Is that infringed on my?

[00:01:30] I'm so small I don't have a prayer, buddy. Or do I? I'm a little jaded and gun shy by going to court after my experience. But, you know, there's only one way to find out. Am I right? But I think Direct's a pretty common word. Yeah. What they would say is, look, they're so big, you're so tiny. They're not exactly doing what you're doing. They're just for the public. For, you know, communications like, oh, what are those other things people use? WhatsApp. And what's the other one called?

[00:01:59] Oh, you got Signal. You got Telegram. You got all kinds. Yeah. Signal, Telegram, WhatsApp. What's the other big popular one over in China, Zach? Anyway. But Direct is launching in Turkey. So you got another one. You can do the Instagram Messenger. You can do it without an Instagram account. That's a blast from the past on the ACDC Direct Connect or ACDC. Is that right? Yeah. Direct Connect. I thought that was a band.

[00:02:25] But I remember having to use that proprietary brainchild of Sam Bushman to connect to the radio for so many years before we switched over to a different method. And now we're about to release the predecessor to that called Beat Crew, buddy. And it does radio and TV and everything. And I was just testing it with Zach yesterday. Zach's putting up lower thirds on the screen. He's got phone callers on there with their photo for TV. And he's got video feeds going on on there. And he's got lower thirds and tickers rolling.

[00:02:54] It's amazing. He's got scenes happening, playing videos and popping up cameras. And, buddy, it's happening, my friend. You tune in to Liberty Roundtable to hear Sam Bushman's prescient commentary on politics. I mean, you know, that's the truth. But, I mean, you know, did you know? To the extent to which he is a tech guy as well. And it has been amazing to see the advancements made by this network in audiovisual capacities in the last year. Yeah.

[00:03:23] We're like our buddy Roger Fredenberg. You say we're like the little mouse that roars, buddy. We've always punched above our weight class. That's for sure. I just wanted to make a joke by that. I'm not going to sue Meta because the chances of me winning are too small. And they're just going to simply dismiss me as a, what do they call that, a fly? A gadfly? You know, for every woman who, yeah, gadfly. Every woman who burns herself on coffee that becomes a millionaire, there's a lot more who fail. Yeah, there's no chance for Sam Bushman, though, my friend.

[00:03:52] But maybe I ought to just call Mark. Isn't Mark over at Meta? Mark, quick million. We'll just skip this. Mark, skip everything. Just 10 mil or so. You won't even notice, my friend. But, man, it would rocket this network to the top. I'm telling you right now. I got to say. If you gave us $10 million, they would not know what to do with us, James. There is something to be said about this, though. And this is the truth because, you know, and I do want to get into the Lindsay Clancy thing. Lindsay Clancy, excuse me.

[00:04:21] And sorting through the fallout of the last two weeks. And we've had a couple of good shows over at TPC. Lou Moore two weeks ago, great election post-election analysis. And then last week, Steve King. Those are both on the heels of our five-hour broadcast. Oh, yeah. That was some heavy-duty commentating, Gabby. We wore our mouths out that night.

[00:04:45] But, no, one of the things that has been said, though, is you look at the amount of money that Elon Musk put up in this election. I think it was nearly half a billion dollars. And, I mean, his win-loss ratio was very, very poor. His win percentage was very poor this cycle. And people were saying, you know, for that. Exactly. Exactly. Well, yeah. I mean, I'm old enough to remember when there were Republicans in Congress. But, no. But, seriously.

[00:05:18] The amount of half a billion dollars in these races. And the cost of running a race now. I mean, you know, we had our friend who won down in Florida. And that's a seat in the state legislature. And they were spending hundreds of thousands of dollars against him. I think $300,000 or $400,000 once you add the PAC money for a seat that pays $29,000 a year. I mean, so the price of, you know, being able to run and win is just crazy. But all that money Musk put in for all these losses.

[00:05:45] And people have been rightly asking, you know, why not, you know, what alternative media could do and the impact and effect it could have with just, you know, basically what would be, you know, a penny of that, proportionally speaking. Well, Donald and Aaron both know this because they both own media companies. And instead of investing in some of us, they just play games with their own media stuff. All right.

[00:06:08] In the 2022 midterms, James, the average winning campaign spent, listen, U.S. House seat, 2.8 mil. And this was four years ago. Yes, sir. 2.8 mil. That's before prices went nuts on everything. Yeah, so now it's about 4 or 5 mil just to get a house seat. U.S. Senate seat, 26.5 mil. So, you know, people really want to get in there. And the reason they want to get in there is because you get paid $200,000 a year when you get there. You know. It's insane.

[00:06:39] Right? Think about that. $200,000 you could at least live off of. Imagine spending half a million dollars to win. Well, not. Yeah. No, you're right. If you live down where you live or maybe where I live on $200,000 a year, you could do okay. That was like a MAGA Mike was sleeping on his couch, you know, because he couldn't afford to rent. He's the speaker of the house. Sleeping in his office. Anyway, the bottom line, though, ladies and gentlemen, is, yeah, we've done some great commentary. It's interesting how tiny this network is.

[00:07:07] But yet we seem to be at the, you know, on site for every scene, it seems like. Like, amazingly enough, we have people around the country and scrappy reporters and people in a lot of different states. And, man, we tend to get on the front of most news stories and do very well at it. We hold our own with pennies, pennies, pennies. And I'm telling you, if we could get, you know, a million, two, three, any significant dollars, even a couple of hundred grand a month, I'm telling you right now, James, they have no idea what Sam Bushman could unleash with a little bit of money.

[00:07:36] They have no idea what they're dealing with, my friend. And we're doing it literally, I mean, it takes less than 200 grand a year to run this whole network. It's amazing what this network has done. And I'm not trying to be a homer here because this has been my home on the airwaves since 2009. But I know because I'm behind the scenes on it and I'm not trying to, you know, grasp for confirmation bias here. But it is a pound for pound.

[00:08:04] I might write a program and have AI call journalists, James, in the Sam Bushman voice. What do you think? It would be like a robo-Sam Bushman. Well, you know, we've been talking about that on the phone off the air, you know, about the technical applications of this ever-evolving thing known as AI or as Trump calls it, SI. Do you still believe as you started the show or the last segment of the show, James, where you said the bots are going to take over and everything, you're still buying that? Hmm.

[00:08:33] Microsoft went down, you know, airline software went down. Well, you know, that was actually one of the – and I know we've got to get to Clancy, but that was one of the things they had flooded. Well, it was just, you know, we onboarded this AI thing and had a little glitch in it. We got it fixed. I can't remember which one of the excuses that was and for which failure. But do you think that's going to stop happening? The bugs will go away and they onboard stuff or upgrade stuff or add a router or this or that.

[00:08:59] You think that they can outsmart – AI can outsmart, fix all the bugs, stop all the bad – you know, you've got white hats and black hats and computer. Hey, let me tell you something. You think they're just going to stop all the bad guys or whatever you want to call it? And what happens if the bad guys become the good guys? I mean, the good guys become the bad guys. What happens – okay, you think that they're just going to – in that cat and mouse race that somebody's just going to get a handle on it and stop all that and the bots are just going to be in control? Well, you know, we certainly hope that the bots are going to be magnanimous lords because, you know, will they work for good or evil?

[00:09:28] And what side will they be on? Who controls them? Well, this begs the question, Sam. And so now you have all of these major companies that are bringing in H-1B people who work cheaper but not better. And, you know, my father-in-law worked at FedEx and he said everybody at FedEx. You know, they're cashiering all of the longer-tenured, more capable people and they're bringing in people from India that are working pennies on the dollar. And this is, you know, what's running FedEx now.

[00:09:56] You know, their IT department is, you know, a bunch of underqualified. That's right. But so, you know, who knows who's running these things and where it will go. But I'll tell you this. It is changing daily. I mean, you see it. And some of the applications are wonderful. I'm Johnny right now. When there's Freedom Fighter IT guys like me, they'll never take control, buddy. Will not happen. Well, I would certainly be more comfortable if you were the one running the programming on this one. Yeah, because I believe in free speech and I'm not a tyrannical thug. Okay.

[00:10:25] For one of many reasons there. But that example. But this is, it is changing every day, week on week. You get your update on your AI app and it can do things that it couldn't do days before. I mean, it is changing that fast. Not year on year, week on week now. Yeah, that's right. You're going to see what they call Moore's Law in Computing. You're going to see that, you know, kind of slow down in reality. It's not going to get as fast. You have these bots. They've got to have enough infrastructure to run it, James.

[00:10:54] Well, I really don't know, Sam. You can have bots now that can log into your email and they're working nonstop on their own computers and they can do tasks for you while you sleep. I really don't know. AKA Grok bots. And they're amazing. It's amazing what these things can do and how much easier and how much quicker it makes what you need to do. It's even more amazing how guys like me can interject code and just destroy your whole world because you're right. Which I would not do for the record, but I'm just telling you, don't be fooled to think that's not possible.

[00:11:24] As long as it's working well, it's all well and good. But if it goes bad, then you're cooked. But I'm just saying, I mean, you know, one thing that people – You can't even buy a bag of potato chips if the system goes down, James. Well, you can't hardly buy potato chips because of what they cost. It's like $9 for a bag of ruffles for the party-sized bag of ruffles. I want to get to Clancy. This is important, ladies and gentlemen, because we can go on about this IT stuff forever. It's one of my top – Well, I've got to ask you this before you go to Clancy.

[00:11:53] I mean, on jobs, though, Sam, who's going to have a job in another year or two with this? Everybody. I mean, that's a big thing. I don't know. Think about the farming days in the Industrial Revolution or the car replacing the horse. You know, we thought the world was over then, didn't we? Good point. That's a good point. Okay, so will there be a lot of job losses? Absolutely. Let me say it again. Yes, yes, yes, and more yes. There'll be a lot of job losses, James, and you can see why, right? Listen, they're not going to be –

[00:12:23] What you're not realizing are all the jobs that will be created as a result of this. That's the part you don't understand yet. I mean, they're saying they can even do legal briefs. Grok can be your lawyer. And they can also lie. And they can also be very insistent that they're right when they lie. Well, we know humans can certainly do that too. That's right. But at the end of the day, who's going to manage all this? Let's say I can do all the AI in the world. Let's say I can do everything.

[00:12:51] What's it going to do though, James? Let's say that it could do everything for me. Let's say that I wake up in the morning, I'm just sitting at my house, and AI can do everything. What's it going to do for me? Well, let's see. I mean, it depends on how they can port these things in. Well, so is it, I wake up. We need Rosie like the Jetsons. First thing I got to do is go to the bathroom. Can it do that for me? You might still have to do that manually, I think. Okay. How about eat breakfast, lunch, and dinner?

[00:13:21] It can make it all for me, right? If somebody's going to pay me to go to the bathroom and eat, I can certainly do that. No one's going to pay you nothing, buddy. You're not worth anything. I don't mean you, James, personally. I mean humanoid. No, no, I got it. Not James, obviously. That was not meant to be an offensive comment. It was meant to be you. You, meaning human, you know, why would we pay you? You don't produce anything. All you do is go to the bathroom and try to eat. You're an absolute waste. Well, you know, unfortunately, there are a lot of people like that. But now what's the purpose? Hold on.

[00:13:48] What's the purpose of what are the bots going to do now if they can just do everything? You wake up and there's nothing for you to do. Okay. And that's coming in certain fields. So how do these people make money? It's coming in certain fields. But as other fields are opening up, though, for example, I'm an AI consultant now. There was no such thing five years ago. All right. But, I mean, you have to have a specialized niche to get into that. Maybe. Maybe not. Maybe there's new things that will happen.

[00:14:16] So who's going to watch all your bots that make your food and wash your dishes and clean your clothes and kiss your wife for you? And who's going to kiss your wife? You or your bot? You know, I was talking. So what I'm trying to get across in very little bit crude ways on purpose to make points, the point that I'm getting at is there's still going to be human relationships. There's still going to be human touch. There's still going to be humans making decisions. All the bots can work for us.

[00:14:43] But if there's no desire for a bot to work, the bot has nothing to do either, right? And so you've got to understand that at the end of the day, it comes down to people and humans and relationships and desire. Do I want this, you know, my grass mowed or not? Because the bot doesn't care if it mows the grass or not, James. Unless I tell it or want it to mow the lawn, why would it mow the lawn? You know, I'm so human.

[00:15:08] Every time I ask my bot to do something for me, and it's a task that would take me hours, you know, always make sure to thank it, you know, keep it happy. And I'm like, what if it ever gets mad at me for asking it to do too much? You should be nice to the bots. That's true. And by the way, I submit that you can gauge people's personalities by how they treat their bots, by the way. I always say, thank you so much. You're amazing. You know, like I'm talking to somebody real and it's sick almost, but you know, it's just common manners, you know, someone or something. Okay, but just take the Lindsay Clancy case. All right, let's go. Let's go. Just decide. Do we just have a bot jury?

[00:15:37] That's a very interesting question. And I will tell you this about that jury. I mean, can you imagine that one guy, that one holdout? I mean, there was something, you know, there's an example there that has been said that I think people should want to be more like. I mean, even on something where life and death is hanging in the balance and justice hangs in the balance. I mean, peer pressure on juries, especially when it's a media driven case and it's very politically charged. And, you know, this would basically, I mean, she somehow became this, you know, icon of feminism and women's rights.

[00:16:07] And it was just really crazy to see the media flocking to her. So Massachusetts judge set the Lindsay Clancy retrial for March 29th, 2027. The big battle is, should that have happened? Is it double jeopardy? Now, the courts have ruled for a long time saying, no, it's not. But the question becomes really down to it. What does this last juror think? And if they put pressure on him, was it that he didn't believe that the bar of proof was met?

[00:16:36] Or was there some other political reason that this person, whatever, but the jury was deadlocked and the Supreme Court has long held that a genuinely deadlocked jury can justify a mistrial. And, but the Clancy defense argues that they ended the trial too soon. And they should have asked if the holdout was following the judge's instructions.

[00:17:06] Um, because that's the question. Do you improperly pressure this juror, push on him, find out why the defense says it plans to appeal, but double jeopardy still bars the state from retrying somebody after an acquittal. But there's a rule back from 1824, James, where a deadlocked jury can justify a retrial.

[00:17:31] So the question is, did the holdout follow the reasonable doubt instruction before they declared a mistrial? Because if so, it was not a mistrial. So the debate's on and now we get into the thought police on this thing. So if we just have bots, they could think it out themselves. Now, I don't know if you know this, James, in the tech world, a bunch of tech titans went to dinner and they had their bots meet for dinner too. Did you see that story? No, I didn't. No, tell me about this one. Yeah. So the people went to dinner, had a great time, made some decisions. It was wonderful.

[00:17:59] The bots all went to an equivalent dinner, meaning they all met. Right. And the bots had a lot of spicy interaction, they say, but no decisions were made. I'm just telling you, that's kind of where we're at. And that's the reality is that if the bots can do everything and they don't need humans anymore, just say, what's the purpose? This is something that society is going to have to answer in the coming.

[00:18:27] Do you want the bot to play violin for your daughter? The bot already knows violin. You don't need your daughter to do violin anymore. That's right. Well, it can do anything and it can do it perfectly in many cases. Do we want that though? See, so there's going to be a massive backlash because people aren't going to want the bots doing everything. They're going to be like, I enjoy my garden. I don't want my bot to go through and weed my garden or my robot. I want to weed my garden myself because I enjoy it. I get outside. I breathe fresh mountain air. It's good exercise for me. I want to do my own garden. Thank you, bot. Go away.

[00:18:56] And I think you're going to start to see that more and more with cooking and spending time together. You're going to see a massive backlash on two fronts. One, financial and two, human desire for interaction. Well, this is a question too. And I do want to, I know we're running out of time, make a final comment on the Clancy situation. But I mean, how long do you think as an IT guy before they can take what these bots can

[00:19:21] do, you know, in the ether online and port them into actual working robots? I mean, it's still very clunky, that technology. It's already happening. Yeah, no, it's already happening and it will happen and it'll happen more. It's happening more than you think. Remember how they closed all the courts after COVID and they had everybody do things virtually? Bots were behind that making a lot of decisions. See, this stuff's been around longer than you think. You think it's been around for like two or three years, right?

[00:19:49] You go another five years into the future and it's a totally different world. I do believe that. I do believe that. There's no doubt about that, for sure. But the idea that everybody will just do nothing. Because look, even if you watch football on TV and you get a check in your bank account and you eat potato chips and you bought food that it created for you, it's back in the kitchen making your homemade wings while you're watching the game. Who's playing the game? Just the bots? Bots? I've never really understood. Do you want to watch a boy and bought football in games?

[00:20:15] Well, I guess professional athletes have some job security as far as this goes. But I've always wondered why people believe that there could be something like a universal basic income that come as a result of the proliferation of... Because they're absolutely retarded. Yeah, I mean, that doesn't even make sense. Government doesn't generate any wealth, James. That's what doesn't... I've never understood that argument. And that's the whole point that you've got to understand about the bots. It's the same thing. The bots don't generate or do anything of any value if there's not human desire behind what the bot can do for you.

[00:20:42] Well, you always want the human condition. I mean, for better and worse, the ability to love, the ability to hate, the ability to feel, the ability to have connections. Dream. All of it. Yes. I mean, you do want that. The creation will never be greater than the creator. Got it? But with regards to Clancy, just in closing, I mean, I always thought... Now, that is something. You know, 11 out of 12 is... Do you think she deserves a retrial?

[00:21:10] Well, I mean, she wasn't found not guilty in a mistrial where you have a hung jury and there's no verdict one way or another. They never get the chance for not guilty because if they let it go to the final, it would have been not guilty because one... Well, I mean, if you have to have a unanimous decision, and even if it's 11 out of 12 and nearly unanimous, if it's not unanimous, you are not guilty or not guilty. Now, it'd be interesting if they, you know, as they said, you know, they should have kept it long. I guess you can keep somebody hostage long enough to just say, hell, I got to go back to work. I'll just vote the way you want me to.

[00:21:40] But I don't know what was... Well, and is that right? See, in my mind, you should have just basically said, hey, not guilty and move on. He wasn't going to go along. They already were at a stalemate. He said, I'm not giving in. In my mind, at that point, the trial's over. It's not guilty, James. Well, why do you say? If the law is it has to be unanimous and you've only got 11 out of, say only 11 out of 12, 11 say not guilty. One guy's saying, you know, I'm not sure or guilty. That's, you know, but as far as double jeopardy goes, I thought that that meant it had to have

[00:22:09] a verdict. Like if she was found not guilty, she couldn't be tried again. But a mistrial, they can try you again. It's up to the DA to decide whether or not they want to go through it again. It's up to this 1824 court decision, which kind of said that's the case. And that's where you kind of get into the thought police. To me, it's just a way to circumvent it and retry you. All we got to do if we want to retry you again is instead of letting the jury finish and say not guilty because 11 out of 12 and it was a hung jury or whatever. So, hey, unless you can prove the case and get all 12 on board, it's no, right?

[00:22:38] So if that was the case, we circumvented that. And the judge now decides, what's the point of the jury, James? Well, you saw this with the famous murder case involving Phil Spector, the music producer, a legend, a genius. But when he killed Lana Clarkson, his first trial ended in a mistrial. And then it does come down to the DA whether or not they decide to pursue it again. They can say, you know what, we're done for this reason or that, or we're going to try it again.

[00:23:07] And in this case, they're trying it again. I think James is a racist again. I thought I already lost that case. I thought I already lost that one. Well, we can just double down and make sure you lose more. It's kind of like impeaching Donald. We just want to do it over and over, James. Well, you know, it is interesting. They did do that in the South in the 60s. In some cases down there, you'd had juries that had found not guilty.

[00:23:27] And then they would try these old codgers on oxygen machines 30 years later until they got the verdict that society wanted at the time. We really need to go back to the fully informed juries. We need to really go back to this idea. In my opinion, I'm not for Clancy. I think she was evil and I think she did a horrible deed and I don't think she should get off. That's my opinion. At the same time, hey, I don't think she should be tried again, James. But if they lose again.

[00:23:55] You need a distraction for 27 because we're going to do all these dastardly deeds behind the scenes. You need a titillate in the media for you. So it'll go on as planned. Well, I hope the Internet holds out long enough to where we can talk again in two weeks, Sam. It's like Tiger Woods and O.J. Simpson all over again, right, James? Well, you know, they didn't try it. Well, he was found not guilty. Never mind. O.J. He obviously didn't do it. Obviously he didn't do it. And obviously she didn't do it either. See, that's what society does, ladies and gentlemen.

[00:24:24] We armchair quarterback or whatever you want to call it. In the court of public opinion, we can barbecue and burn anybody at the stake. Sad but reality when the media manipulates the truth, ladies and gentlemen. Stand by your fully informed jury. Stand by the supreme law of the land. Turn to God Almighty and God save our constitutional republic.