Casey Harper, John Teichert, Gordon Chang, Kate Anderson, Johnnie Moore
Washington WatchNovember 19, 202600:54:0249.48 MB

Casey Harper, John Teichert, Gordon Chang, Kate Anderson, Johnnie Moore

The Washington Stand’s Casey Harper provides an overview of the trilateral meeting between Presidents Trump, Xi, and Putin in China, as well as the meetings with Jared Kushner, Steve Witkoff, and President Zelenskyy in Berlin. Brig. Gen. (Ret.) John Teichert, former Assistant Deputy Under Secretary for the Air Force for International Affairs, offers greater context to the Trump-Putin-Xi meeting in China and the ongoing war in Ukraine. Gordon Chang, Distinguished Senior Fellow at the Gatestone Institute, explores the significance of the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) Economic Leaders' Meeting, along with the discussions between Presidents Trump, XI, and Putin on artificial intelligence and nuclear negotiations. Kate Anderson, Director of Alliance Defending Freedom’s Center for Parental Rights, details a case in Minnesota where two fathers contend that the state is excluding religious education from publicly available education tax benefits and discriminating against families who choose to educate their children according to their religious beliefs. Rev. Johnnie Moore, Vice Chancellor and Managing Director of Middle East Studies at Pepperdine University in Washington, D.C., discusses the decline in voter turnout among evangelical Christians.

[00:00:01] From the heart of our nation's capital in Washington, D.C., bringing compelling interviews, insightful analysis, taking you beyond the headlines and soundbites into conversations with our nation's leaders and newsmakers, all from a biblical worldview. Sitting in for Tony is today's host, Jody Heiss.

[00:00:18] No peace was ever forged by declining opportunities for engagement and speech. Together, we're choosing a different course. A historic summit offers us the chance to seek out new opportunities and approaches on a range of very important issues, most of them everybody in this room knows, and hopefully to create a better future for all of us.

[00:00:43] That was President Trump earlier today speaking about his trilateral meeting with the Chinese President Xi Jinping and Russian President Vladimir Putin. Welcome to this Thursday, November 19th edition of Washington Watch. I'm Jody Heiss. So glad to have you joining us today.

[00:01:01] Coming up on the program, despite high expectations, the unprecedented trilateral meeting among leaders of the United States, China and Russia yielded little more than a symbolic peace declaration. China expert Gordon Chang will offer his analysis of the meeting and its potential implications going forward.

[00:01:23] The war in Ukraine was also on the agenda, but Putin doubled down on his determination to continue the assault. Retired Brigadier General John Teichert will be with us. He says Putin cannot be trusted and should not be legitimized on the world stage. Plus, what's behind the decline in evangelical turnout in the midterm elections? Family Research Council President Tony Perkins will be joined by Reverend Johnny Moore.

[00:01:53] He's vice chancellor and managing director of Middle East Studies at Pepperdine University in D.C. He'll assess the factors behind this precarious trend. Frankly, one can only imagine what the future will look like if many evangelicals remain largely missing in action.

[00:02:47] Stay with us. Other than the surface appearance, was anything actually accomplished at the meeting? I mean, there seems to be a significant lack of concrete commitments as it relates to global security issues. Yeah, Jody. I mean, if you're a widow in Ukraine or live off the southwest, off the beach on the southwest coast of Taiwan, you're probably a little disappointed with what came out of this. But, you know, they are talking and that's very important diplomacy.

[00:03:16] And the leaders did reaffirm that nuclear war must never be fought. And that was really important for President Trump. He was driving that issue coming into these meetings. But to your point, no specific deals or commitments on arms controls. We do have a clip of President Trump earlier today. The world's three largest nuclear powers by far. The United States, Russia and China are uniquely positioned to discuss how to reduce the number of nuclear weapons on Earth.

[00:03:44] And also to lessen the risk that those weapons will ever be used. The power is unbelievable, unthinkable. Now, President Trump did say that artificial intelligence was discussed with Chinese President Xi Jinping. He also briefly mentioned former NVIDIA CEO Jensen Huang. But to your point about no hard deals being struck, at least on AI, President Trump doesn't want them. He does not want and he's made clear that he doesn't want global regulation of AI or anything that could stifle AI development.

[00:04:14] And now something we've been watching closely is whether human rights violations and persecution of minorities in China, including the imprisonment of Christian pastors and closure of churches, which, you know, you and I have talked about on this program before. At least right now, we don't have any indication that that that was addressed at these discussions. But I'll let you know if we get more word on that one, Jody. Thank you for that, Casey.

[00:04:38] And speaking of Ukraine, U.S. Envoys Jared Kushner and Steve Witkoff met with Ukrainian President Zelensky in Berlin today. Can you tell us anything about that meeting and whether or not there was any progress towards a potential peace deal? Yeah, I mean, many of these meetings are played very close to the chest. But Jared Kushner did say that President Trump is open to providing Ukraine with security guarantees as part of a potential deal with Russia.

[00:05:04] And you've been hearing that phrase security guarantees time and again, especially out of the mouth of Vladimir Zelensky. That has been a drum he's been beating for a long time. He's probably happy to hear that. Now, at the same time, the U.S.-European talks in Berlin made progress on those security guarantees, but also Ukraine's post-war recovery plan. In fact, here's what Jared Kushner had to say. We've made a lot of progress working with President Zelensky and the Coalition of the Willing on what those security guarantees can look like.

[00:05:32] We've also been making a lot of progress on a post-war prosperity plan. And we've been working with the World Bank and BlackRock and President Zelensky's team. And the EU has really been excellent at spearheading that effort. And I think that we've made progress towards defining what a successful and strong Ukraine can look like, hopefully after this war. Now, Kushner also said Russia agreed to a multilateral negotiating framework that includes European representatives.

[00:05:57] European leaders, for their part, and NATO and U.S. envoys as well, met in Berlin to coordinate efforts to end this war in Ukraine, an issue we're going to be following very closely at the Washington State. And Jody. All right, Casey, thank you so much for these updates. We appreciate it. Let's turn back now to some of the meetings that President Trump has recently had, which included an individual meeting with Russia's Vladimir Putin. Joining us now is retired Brigadier General John Teichert.

[00:06:26] He's a former combat pilot and former assistant deputy undersecretary of the Air Force for International Affairs. He also served as commander of Joint Base Andrews, as well as Edwards Air Force Base. General Teichert, welcome back to Washington Watch. Always good to have you with us. And let's begin with the meeting between Trump and Putin in China today.

[00:06:48] What is your overall assessment of whether these talks moved us any closer to ending Russia's war with Ukraine? Jody, thanks for having me. And it didn't move us any closer, but I think a lot of us were holding our breath to make sure that it wouldn't move us further away. And while that didn't seem to be any substantial breakthroughs in the talks,

[00:07:12] we didn't see the president of the United States give up on anything that would have been in the best interest of U.S. long-term security. And to some extent for all of us, that's a bit of a win. You had a commentary earlier this week in the Washington stand, and in it you warned against rewarding Putin for his aggression. And I think that was so appropriate.

[00:07:38] How do you think that type of warning should shape the administration's approach to these negotiations? Jody, that piece in the Washington stand was actually generated because of a quote I came across from 2024 from late Senator Lindsey Graham that said, the more that you reward thugs like Putin for doing bad things, the more bad things you're going to get.

[00:08:03] And it's a great reminder to all of us, especially against malign actors like Xi or like Putin or like the supreme leader Kim Jong-un in North Korea, that if you incentivize bad behavior, then you're going to get it. If you recognize or reward bad behavior, you're going to get it. And all of those malign actors are enticed by American weakness or capitulation or appeasement.

[00:08:29] And the only language they respect and understand is strength, capability, will, and resolve. And we've got to stop vacillating between being on the right side of history and being on the wrong side of history. And being on the wrong side of history is being friends with malign actors and giving up the moral high ground by not talking about the important humanitarian issues that the United States should always stand for.

[00:08:55] And instead, giving up that moral high ground is a detriment to our ability to achieve our long-term strategic and security interests. Extremely well said. And I think spot on to the point. Let me ask you this in regard to the latest on the war itself. As we all have seen now, the bridge that Ukraine struck, the Kirch Bridge connecting Russia to occupied Crimea.

[00:09:22] Putin is obviously threatening retaliation for that. But from a military standpoint, how significant are those strikes as it relates to Ukraine's efforts to weaken Russia's position? Jody, just in the last several months, we've seen a lot of very positive operational and strategic gains by Ukraine over Russia. Ukraine has been taking back territory in the last several months.

[00:09:50] That the economic situation in Russia, according to their own central bank, is bleak and the future is dismal. And now cutting off the supply lifeline to Russian-occupied Crimea is a significant step by the striking of this bridge. And really, the only two things that Russia now has going for it, number one is they've got a ballistic missile fleet and Ukraine has problems shooting those down with a lack of interceptors.

[00:10:16] And number two, Russia has been emboldened by some of the vacillation and fickle policies by the United States. We gave them two lifelines in 2026. Sanction relief in the spring and sanction relief in the diesel deal a couple of months ago. Those things embolden and empower Putin and actually allow the Russian economy to continue to function.

[00:10:39] And if we would have never done those things or if we would stop doing them, then all of those military gains by Ukraine could be complemented by U.S. policy. And we could actually see a quicker end to the war. I know you've been sounding that trumpet for quite a while. You've been calling for stronger economic pressure, including targeting Russia's oil shipping networks and using some of the frozen Russian assets.

[00:11:06] So between those and maybe some other things that you have in mind, what type of economic measures would give Washington the greatest leverage to try to get Putin to seriously negotiate this thing? Jody, first of all, let's stop sanction relief and be consistent about supporting Ukraine and recognizing that it is Russia that is the aggressor here and Ukraine that is the victim.

[00:11:34] But I think there are two specific additional items that we could follow through on. Number one, that there are $300 billion of frozen Russian central bank assets in the possession of the United States and Western Europe. And I think that we should permanently seize a portion of those every time we see malign behavior by Russia. And that would disincentivize instead of incentivizing their continuing of this war.

[00:12:01] And then number two, there's a very large shadow tanker fleet that Russia utilizes around the world to avoid or evade sanctions. And if us and our allies and partners started taking out those shadow tanker assets, then it would put a significant pressure on the economy of Russia alongside of us taking a stand against them. It would start helping Putin to understand that it is in his best interest not to continue the war, but to stop the war.

[00:12:32] All right, I've only got about a minute left, but if, and a big if, if negotiations were to produce some sort of ceasefire, what kind of assurance would Ukraine need to make sure that Russia would not use that pause to simply rebuild its forces and then attack again? Jody, any sort of deal to end the war is going to come down to a tradeoff between economic factors, geographical factors and security factors.

[00:12:59] But I was heartened to hear Jared Kushner talk about security guarantees in the clip you played before this interview, because it's going to be essential to make sure we put a security guarantee structure in place so that Putin does not feel enticed or incentivized to restart a war after a ceasefire or the end of this phase of the conflict.

[00:13:21] And really the only way to do that is to have a speed bump of NATO and U.S. forces that are there so that Putin would know that we are determined to ensure the ceasefire and the end of the war instead of just giving them another pass to start phase three. Thank you, as always, retired Brigadier General John Teichert. Great to have you. Thanks for joining us. Coming up, we'll look at today's meetings in China and what they accomplished, what they didn't accomplish.

[00:13:51] We'll discuss what's at stake in regard to artificial intelligence and nuclear weapons. Gordon Chang, China expert, joins us next. One nation under God. America's undeniable foundation of faith. Yousef from Family Research Council here in Washington, D.C.

[00:14:19] We're continuing the celebration of 250 years of our home sweet home by walking the historic streets of our nation's capital today. And if you were here walking around with me, you would see the timeless architecture, iconic statues and solemn memorials that grace this city. All of it designed to tell our nation's story.

[00:14:40] If you look closely, if you seek, you will find that these monuments still whisper to those who listen that God has been at work in America from the beginning. So for he who has ears, let him hear the frozen music of these monuments and buildings. Because the song sounds something like this. America, America, God shed his grace on thee. Consider the Washington Monument, over 500 feet of stone soaring into the sky.

[00:15:10] The highest point in Washington, D.C. Written at the top of the monument are the words, Laus Deo, Latin for praise be to God. So when the sun rises on Washington, D.C., our praise rises with it. Head to the White House. Imagine sharing a meal in the state dining room. There you will find this prayer from President John Adams carved into the mantle above the fireplace. I pray to heaven to bestow the best of blessings on this house.

[00:15:39] May none but honest and wise men ever rule under this roof. At the center of the U.S. Capitol, the home of Congress, eight grand paintings rest in the rotunda. A friar holds a cross as Columbus and his crew land in the Americas. Pocahontas is baptized in a Jamestown church in 1613. Before crossing the Atlantic, the pilgrims pray over an open Bible. The words, God with us, on the sails of their ship.

[00:16:09] Go to the Jefferson Memorial. Engraved on the wall are these stirring words. Indeed, I tremble for my country when I reflect that God is just. That his justice cannot sleep forever. Walk by the Supreme Court, the highest court in the land. And find Moses sculpted into the top of the building's east entrance, holding the Ten Commandments. What more can I say? I do not have time to tell about Asbury and Witherspoon, Hamilton and Grant, FDR's D-Day prayer, or Lincoln's appeal to God.

[00:16:40] But our nation's story isn't finished. It's still being etched in stone by us. So we can make the promise of America real and the idea of America complete. And that is our foundation of faith. Welcome back to Washington Watch. Thanks for tuning in. Jody Heiss, glad to have you with us.

[00:17:09] Earlier today, President Trump met with Chinese President Xi Jinping and Russian President Vladimir Putin. The meeting took place on the sidelines, if you will, of the AIPAC summit. And the leaders did pledge further dialogue on reducing nuclear risks. And that's nice. But they also announced no agreement to reduce nuclear arsenals.

[00:17:35] So what, if anything, really did these meetings accomplish? And what did they reveal about China's intention? Well, joining us now is Asia expert Gordon Chang. He's senior fellow at the Gate Stone Institute and author of Plan Red, China's project to destroy America. You can follow him on X under the handle at Gordon Chang Gordon, always great to have you back on Washington Watch. Thanks for joining us. Well, thank you so much, Jody.

[00:18:06] So China hosted this summit. China brought President Trump and Vladimir Putin to the table together. On the surface, it would appear from that that China, that Xi Jinping actually comes out the winner here. So first question, would you agree with that? And if so, what did he gain from these meetings? Yeah.

[00:18:30] Xi Jinping, I guess, gains the image of bringing together the three most powerful people in the world. China didn't want this trilateral summit for a lot of reasons. One of them is that Xi Jinping wanted to host the APEX summit in Shenzhen to show off China's technological powerhouse, to how vibrant the Chinese economy is. Now, this trilateral summit took the focus away from that.

[00:18:59] So Xi Jinping, I don't think, was terribly happy. But the big winner of the summit would be Vladimir Putin because he got to sit at the table with the two most powerful people in the world. And that elevated Putin's stature. Got to remember that his country runs a distant third to China and the United States. Good point. So let me ask you this, at least according to China's account of their separate meeting,

[00:19:28] President Xi told President Trump that the U.S. must, quote, do the right thing as it relates to Taiwan in order to avoid any setbacks in relations. What do you think Beijing is trying to get Washington to change about its support for Taiwan specifically? Basically, at this interim point, the Chinese want the United States to oppose Taiwan independence, quote unquote.

[00:19:54] Now, that is sort of a silly statement because our policy is that any resolution of Taiwan status must be peaceful. And therefore, with the consent of the people in Taiwan, we don't support, we don't oppose Taiwan independence. That's part of our one China policy. Really, what ultimately they want is the United States to stand aside as China conquers or annexes Taiwan.

[00:20:23] That's not going to happen either. President Trump has been firm in his support of the island. And so the Chinese are just sort of they do this ritually. They do this at every summit meeting. They just go on and on about this. And we know from Secretary Rubio that the United States just listens politely and then goes on to more important matters. So what about the issue of artificial intelligence? I know that's a hot topic for both China and the U.S. in particular.

[00:20:52] What do you see as the greatest dangers for the U.S. when negotiating on that issue? And even if they make some sort of agreement, can she be trusted? No, they can't be. There have been all sorts of ideas about agreements where each country notifies the other of problems with their AI. I don't think the Chinese are going to reveal that.

[00:21:19] There's also another side issue, which is really important to the Chinese. And that is they do not want additional Commerce Department restrictions on China's access to chips. China can't compete with the U.S. unless it has American semiconductors. And what we're seeing from the NVIDIA fallout are calls both in Congress and in the administration to tighten those rules. And so China does not like that.

[00:21:49] Its initial reaction to the Commerce Department rules of three days ago was to throw a tantrum. And I don't know if this came up in the trilateral summit, but I'm sure that we're going to hear more of this, especially because Xi Jinping is coming to the United States next month to talk to President Trump on the sidelines of the G20 summit. So there's going to be another opportunity for conversation on this and other topics. Well, and that's a big deal for sure.

[00:22:19] And the U.S. has to walk a tightrope in terms of working with AI and probably setting up some sort of guardrails without, at the same time, as you mentioned, providing technology that would strengthen Chinese military. So definitely a tightrope here. Now, let's go to this. China has resisted joining any kind of nuclear arms negotiation. Their argument is that their arsenal is much smaller than those of the United States and Russia.

[00:22:47] So what do you think it would take to get Beijing to accept some sort of meaningful limits in the nuclear arms race, if you will? Probably nothing within the power of President Trump. You know, the Chinese have been adamant. They've been adamant for decades about not talking about the size of its arsenal.

[00:23:10] Also, you know, when Xi Jinping met President Biden in 2023, the Chinese wouldn't even talk to us about the use of AI in the decision to launch nuclear weapons. So, you know, they're very clear about this. And, yes, it would be historic and monumental if President Trump were able to come to a treaty on arms control. But that's a use of diplomatic resources, scarce diplomatic resources.

[00:23:39] That isn't very good for us because President Trump doesn't have the time to arrive at a treaty like that. And the other thing is we need to talk to our friends and partners at this consequential moment because that's the way we're going to defend ourselves, not conversations with militant aggressors, which will not go anywhere.

[00:23:59] Yeah, and I suppose even if some sort of nuclear deal was met, still there's got to be some sort of method to ensure that China and Russia actually would honor their commitments. And I would think that that also, particularly, as you said, in the short period of time that President Trump has remaining in office, that's a pretty big hurdle to overcome. All right, thank you so much for joining us today. Gordon Chang, Senior Fellow at the Gate Stone Institute.

[00:24:27] Always a powerful discussion to have his expertise on the program with us. Coming up, we've got a couple of Minnesota fathers. They are challenging their state regarding a policy that excludes religious instruction and materials from education when it comes to tax breaks. So is Minnesota discriminating against families because of their faith? We'll examine that next. Stay with us.

[00:25:02] One Nation Under God. America's Undeniable Foundation of Faith. As president of the College of New Jersey, now known as Princeton University, John Witherspoon taught 10 cabinet members, 60 members of Congress, 13 governors, three Supreme Court justices, Vice President Aaron Burr and President James Madison.

[00:25:27] As a Presbyterian minister, Witherspoon was the only active clergyman to sign the Declaration of Independence. He was a gifted preacher and writer who let his faith direct his political activism, often voicing the link between earthly liberty and spiritual liberty. Witherspoon argued there is not a single instance in history in which civil liberty was lost and religious liberty preserved entire. President John Adams said of Witherspoon,

[00:25:55] he was a true son of liberty, but first he was the son of the cross. Witherspoon's views on man's sinfulness from birth influenced his belief that self-government was only possible with checks and balances, a belief he passed on to his student, James Madison, father of the Constitution. Witherspoon helped form the vision many of our founding fathers held to, no republic without liberty, no liberty without virtue, and no virtue without religion.

[00:26:22] And with that, Witherspoon became a cornerstone in America's foundation of faith. Get your copy of FRC's newest book, Battlefield Faith. Using letters, diaries, sermons, memoirs, and eyewitness accounts, Battlefield Faith takes you on a journey through the early battles of the American Revolution. Uncover remarkable stories of commanders, chaplains, and ordinary soldiers

[00:26:48] who prayed, trusted God, and risked everything in America's fight for freedom. Order your copy today. Text BATTLE to 67742. The following segment of Washington Watch is underwritten by Patriot Mobile, a champion of First and Second Amendment rights, military, veterans, first responders, and a strong supporter of the sanctity of life. To learn more about Patriot Mobile's nationwide service across all three major U.S. networks,

[00:27:17] go to TonyPerkins.com. And welcome back to Washington Watch. I'm Jody Heiss. So glad to have you tuning in with us today. There are two Minnesota fathers. They are suing their state over a policy that provides tax breaks to families for certain educational expenses, but it excludes religious teaching materials and instruction.

[00:27:45] So on Monday, Alliance Defending Freedom filed lawsuit on behalf of these fathers, arguing that parents shouldn't lose access to those benefits because they educate their children according to their Christian faith. And joining us now for a deeper dive into this case is Kate Anderson, Senior Counsel at Alliance Defending Freedom and Director of its Center for Parental Rights. Kate, welcome back to Washington Watch. Always good to have you. Thanks for having me on the show.

[00:28:16] Okay, before we get to the specifics of the lawsuit, let's start, if you would, just explain to us how Minnesota's education tax benefits work and where the state draws the line on religious education. So Minnesota, like several states, have benefits to try to increase access to education for all families, including private school and homeschooling families.

[00:28:39] So they have this tax credit and a deduction program that's open to all families that they can use for educational expenses, for tuition, for curriculum costs, for other things related to their education of their children. But Minnesota specifically excludes religious education. And so in order to take this credit or deduction, the parents have to certify that what they are taking the credit for is secular. And families that teach their kids according to their religious beliefs,

[00:29:09] like our clients, Nathan Kohlstock and Joe Osborne, are not able to make that certification because every aspect of the education they are teaching their kids at home is influenced by their biblical worldview and therefore not secular in nature. So what does this mean for these fathers, these families in practical terms? I mean, have they had to quit their religious instruction or just practically speaking, what has been the impact?

[00:29:37] Well, it means that they're being discriminated against. They are being told that because they're teaching their kids according to their religious beliefs that they do not have access to the same tax credit and deduction benefits as every other family in Minnesota. This means that there's a bigger financial burden on them. They're being penalized for exercising their faith. Faith that the Supreme Court has repeatedly said, even in recent years, parents are the ones who direct their kids' education and upbringing

[00:30:04] and that parents instill those values and that religious upbringing as part of those parental rights and as part of their religious freedom. And so the way this tax benefit is operating, it's directly discriminating against these two fathers and all families in Minnesota that are educating their kids according to their religious beliefs and cannot certify to the government that they're doing anything else. So these families are, and we did this ourselves, my wife homeschooled our children,

[00:30:34] but these families, they teach math and science. They teach history and all these sorts of things, certainly with a Christian worldview, but they teach all these subjects. So what happens when the government tries to separate their faith from the rest of their children's education? I mean, this is a huge step of intrusion by the government, isn't it? It absolutely is. And we're seeing it in similar programs across the country.

[00:31:02] But to look at Minnesota's, it's giving the government the power to decide whether certain education is too religious to be included or whether it's secular. The government shouldn't be in the business of deciding between these things or dictating how parents educate their kids at home, especially when they are trying to fund that kind of education through these sorts of public benefit programs. But time and time again, the Supreme Court has said when the government sets out these kinds of public programs

[00:31:30] that are available to everyone, including those that involve funding, that they cannot discriminate on the basis of religion by excluding certain families, certain curriculum, certain conduct, only because it's religious. And that's exactly what this program does. Now, a moment ago, you referenced the Supreme Court decision protecting religious rights and families as it relates to public benefits. How does that decision apply to this case?

[00:32:01] Well, we're talking about the Trinity Lutheran case, and then there were two that came after it, Espinosa and Carson, all involving funding that was going to religious entities from the government. And the government said we cannot send any money to religious entities. And the court said that's not that bright a line. The bright line is that you can't discriminate against religion. And so when the government sets out state programs that are available to everyone,

[00:32:27] religious people are able to apply and be part of those on equal footing, and they cannot be excluded simply because of the religious nature of what they're doing. So we saw this with playgrounds and reimbursement for playground equipment and flooring at a religious school and church. We've seen it in other education contexts. And here we're seeing it in this tax benefit, where the state is saying you can only be part of this tax benefit

[00:32:53] if you will promise and certify on your taxes that you're not using it for religious education. And a parent that is infusing their worldview into math, history, literature, handwriting, everything that they're doing with their child, they cannot certify that to the government. And the Constitution does not require that. The Constitution requires that they be respected and able to be part of these programs free of religious discrimination. Less than a minute ago, what are you asking the court to do for these families? Or the state?

[00:33:24] We're asking the court to step in and ensure that discrimination stops here, that the parents are able to take part in this credit and deduction on equal footing with secular families, and they are not pushed out simply because of their religious beliefs. All right, Kate Anderson with ADF, thank you so much for joining us on this. A very important case. We'll be keeping our eyes on it. All right, coming up, Tony Perkins will be joined by Reverend Johnny Moore of Pepperdine University for discussion

[00:33:53] on the decline of evangelicals in the voting turnout. Stay with us. Exodus chapter 9 verse 1 says, Thus says the Lord God of the Hebrews, Let my people go that they may serve me. You see, America has freedom for a purpose. The question is, are we living by that purpose today?

[00:34:21] In Scripture, deliverance and freedom is never an end in itself. It is a liberation unto obedience, to worship, and to a covenantal relationship. God's demand to Pharaoh was not freedom for freedom's sake, but freedom so his people could identify with and belong to and serve him. Freedom that is not used to serve God will not endure.

[00:34:51] One of the founders actually echoed a similar warning. Thomas Jefferson wrote, Indeed, I tremble for my country when I reflect that God is just and his justice cannot sleep forever. See, the founders understood we as a nation would be accountable to God for what he had granted to us. They sought freedom for a purpose.

[00:35:20] And that freedom was given to us as a nation for that same purpose, to serve God, to honor him, and to live as a people under his authority. In this 250th anniversary year, we must ask the question, are we living by that purpose today as a nation? Lord, we thank you for the godly foundation

[00:35:48] and heritage of our states. Lord, we would return to an understanding of the freedom that you've granted to us, that freedom has a name. His name is Jesus. And freedom has a purpose. It is to honor and glorify you. And I pray that our nation would return to that understanding of the purpose of the freedom that you have granted to us. We thank you, Father. By faith, we pray that we would return

[00:36:18] to that purpose. In Jesus' name we pray. Amen. Looking for a biblical worldview on today's most important issues? Check out the Outstanding podcast. We dive into hot topics and cultural controversies with the leading experts. From artificial intelligence to transgenderism, abortion to the persecution of the church, Outstanding is determined to examine today's headlines through the lens of Scripture

[00:36:48] and explore how Christians can faithfully exalt Christ in all of life. Follow Outstanding on your favorite podcast app and look for new episodes each week. Back to Washington Watch. Good to have you with us on this Thursday. The website, TonyPerkins.com. Better yet, if you have not yet downloaded the Stand Firm app, I encourage you to do so.

[00:37:15] Lots of resources there on the Stand Firm app. Not only do you have access to Washington Watch, but you can also have access to our news and commentary from a biblical perspective, the Washington Stand, and my daily devotional, Stand on the Word. All of that can be found on the Stand Firm app. Go to the App Store and download it today. All right, another announcement. I'm going to be leading a tour to Israel this coming Easter season. I don't know if you've ever thought about spending Easter in Israel,

[00:37:44] but we're going to be having a sunrise service overlooking the Sea of Galilee on Easter morning, on Resurrection morning. So I encourage you, if you'd like to join us, you can find out more by texting Israel to 67742. That's Israel to 67742. It's a 10-day tour. We'll be there March the 24th through April the 2nd. And we're going to take you to places that most groups won't take you to. So reserve your spot now because it's filling up very quickly.

[00:38:14] That's Israel to 67742. Our word for today comes from Hosea 14. Who is wise? Let him understand these things. Who is prudent? Let him know them. For the ways of the Lord are right. The righteous walk in them, but transgressors stumble in them. The book of Hosea ends with a question that we must answer. Who's wise? God calls Israel to turn from idols and return to him.

[00:38:41] His prophets warned of rebellion's consequences, yet they refused to repent. God was on their lips, but not in their hearts. Hosea concludes with an invitation to return to the Lord, and I promise that God will heal their backsliding and love them freely. Then comes this final test. Do we merely know God's ways, or do we walk in them? Scripture says the fear of the Lord is the beginning of wisdom. True wisdom is not simply intellectual knowledge.

[00:39:11] It's transformational. It changes how we live, what we love, and whom we obey. The righteous walk in God's ways. The rebellious, they stumble over them. The question is not whether we know what God says, but whether we will follow him. To find out more about our journey through the Bible, text Bible to 67742. All right, evangelical Christians remained overwhelmingly loyal

[00:39:38] to Republican candidates in the November 3rd midterm elections, with 82% of white evangelicals who voted supporting the GOP. Now, that might sound like good news for Republicans, but a closer look reveals a troubling trend. According to exit polling and other data that's come out, white evangelicals accounted for just 17% of all the voters. That was down from 24% in the 2022 midterms.

[00:40:05] And new research shows that predominantly Christian counties experienced some of the largest shifts toward Democrats. So were evangelical Christians simply staying home, or are they growing disillusioned with political leaders they've supported? What explains this decline? And what lessons should Christian leaders draw from the election? And what should the Republican Party be doing? Joining us now to discuss this is the Reverend Johnny Moore,

[00:40:35] Vice Chancellor and Managing Director of Middle East Studies at Pepperdine University in Washington, D.C. Johnny previously served as Campus Pastor and Senior Vice President for Communications at Liberty University. He's also the author and co-author of several books, including the new book on Christian martyrs. Johnny, welcome back to Washington Watch. Always good to see you. You too, Tony. Thanks for having me. So let's start with this. What happened to the evangelical vote on November the 3rd?

[00:41:04] We know evangelicals have historically been among the most dependable voters in the Republican coalition. How significant was their decline in participation, and why did it happen? Well, look, I mean, the data gives a lesson that Republicans learn every couple of elections, which is if you take the evangelical vote for granted, you cannot win an election. That's a normal lesson that happens every few elections.

[00:41:32] But the decline here was actually historic. I mean, what you had was you had sort of normal loyalty to the Republican Party, but an absolute collapse in turnout, right? So when evangelical turnout collapses seven or eight points as it did in this election, the result is what you saw, a blue tidal wave, and including in states like Texas, Kansas, and South Carolina. So this was not just a normal wake-up call for the Republican Party, Tony.

[00:41:59] This was one of those sort of come-to-Jesus moments when it comes to the constituency, which represents the indispensable base of the Republican Party. No Republican can win a national or state election in the United States of America without a super, super majority of evangelical support. As you said, this is a lesson that Republicans seem to have to learn every so often.

[00:42:28] But let's talk about the why here, all right? So many of these candidates who lost races in this election cycle had been, you know, on the ballot multiple times before, won, had the support of evangelicals. Their positions had not changed. And I know, look, I know that the economy is a factor for everybody. Affordability, all of that is an issue. But was there some disillusionment with some promises or expectations, maybe I should say,

[00:42:56] from this administration, from the Republicans having both Congress and the administration and not coming forward with it? Yeah, for sure. And there were early warning signs. So, you know, on one level, exactly right. You know, every American concerned about affordability, concerned about gas prices, all of these things, like that's the sort of normative baseline. But there are unique behaviors when it comes to the Republican constituency of the evangelical Republican constituency in the United States.

[00:43:25] And by the way, one cannot wake up after the midterm election and be surprised by this. I mean, these idiosyncrasies are consistent. By the way, one of them relates to Iran. In the 2016 presidential election, if you looked at the top five issues, okay, the top five issues to evangelicals when Donald Trump was elected in 2016, one of those top

[00:43:47] five issues was a opposition to the JCPOA, the infamous Iran deal that was brokered by the Trump administration. I mean, this is like an unbelievably consistent policy when it comes to the evangelical community. You're going to be tough on Iran. That's the view of evangelicals. It's not just about Israel. It's also about the persecution of evangelicals in Iran. And when you look at, you know, put aside the normative factors that affected the entire electorate, put all that data aside. That affects everyone.

[00:44:17] That doesn't really change the outcomes. What changed the outcomes are what are the issues that cause a constituency to not be motivated, to not come out, to come out, in fact, in this case, less than they did in the last midterm election, okay? And I would say there are a few things, some of them anecdotal, some of them in the data. Number one, and a lot of this frankly lands in the portfolio of the vice president of the United States, there was a pretty significant assault on evangelicals, not from the left, but from the right.

[00:44:47] And I think evangelicals felt like they were not sufficiently defended. Number two, you know, the policy when it comes to Israel, you cannot be wishy-washy in any form whatsoever as a Republican on Israel and expect to win an election on the state level or the national level. And the net effect of this MOU with Iran was that it did both things, and it did it within

[00:45:13] the context of a feeling that there were sort of right attacks on evangelical Zionists, on the evangelical community. And then you have a few domestic policies. Let me, let's unpack that one with Iran for just a moment, because I agree with you. I think this has long been an issue for evangelicals. They understand the threat of Iran. They also understand, you know, their tie to terrorism around the world and oftentimes Christians being the target of that.

[00:45:42] I personally supported the president in his actions toward Iran, and I think most evangelicals did. My view is, I think, Johnny, it's more of an execution issue that we, as you said, we've entered these agreements, we've started, stopped, started, stopped, started, stopped, instead of just finishing it. What do you say? No, that's exactly right. And that is perceived as weakness, right? So you have, and again, I'm sorry to say this, you know, because, but it just is the fact

[00:46:11] that a lot of this dwelled on the portfolio of the vice president. So the vice president bet his political future on an MOU. The president allowed him to negotiate the MOU. And the fact of the matter is the MOU didn't lead to the rapid end or victory on the war. It created space for the Iranians to play games. And by the way, entirely predictable. I mean, if you look at the original MOU, you know, the time period for the initial MOU

[00:46:41] took the MOU right up to the midterm elections. And so it seems as if there was some political calculus on the Iranian side that from the very, very beginning had the intention of meddling in domestic politics in the United States. So when you put it all together— So was the vice president—the vice president was played by the Iranian regime? I mean, I think that's what most people think. I think that's just the reality of the situation.

[00:47:07] And it seems like that the president himself—I mean, if you listen to his comments in Shenzhen just yesterday, that he believes the same thing. Now, this is a president for peace. He's willing to negotiate to sit with anyone. And by the way, that's a good thing to do, OK? It's good to, you know, sit across the table. And wars do end with treaties or defeat. But you have to always do it from the position of strength.

[00:47:33] And I think Americans sort of, like, stepped back and said, like, why is Pakistan and Qatar and some of these other countries determining our policy when it comes to this conflict with Iran? And I think that most—and this is not—no one supports, you know, the straw man of a never-ending, forever war. Like, this is—you know, this was like 60 days into what, by the way, is a pretty decisive kinetic victory.

[00:47:58] I mean, the total—when this MOU was implemented, you know, it was implemented when we had already destroyed the Air Force, destroyed the Navy, destroyed the vast majority of all of their munitions. And by the way, the most effective thing in this whole campaign has been the blockade, which only took place after the MOU, you know, was starting to fray. And so, yeah, I mean, I think the perception is that the—whether, you know, it's true or it isn't true, whether he meant it or didn't meant it, that the vice president of the United

[00:48:28] States got played by Iran. Johnny, let me ask you another question on issues related to this, because I think this—what I was hearing, in fact, what I was saying going into this election, in fact, just a week or so out, I was saying, hey, if you want to give the voters basically a shot in the arm of political energy to get them out to vote, is that we needed to address this issue of

[00:48:57] Mifeprestone, the abortion drug. When you look at the fact that abortion rates in this country have actually gone up over 20% since the overturn of Roe, a policy put in place by Biden but kept in place by the Trump administration. That's deflating to pro-life voters who vote on—as you mentioned, all these other issues are out there, but you've got to put those aside when you look at evangelicals and that underlying motivation of enthusiasm. Yeah, I mean, it's all about enthusiasm.

[00:49:27] And when you look at the evangelical constituency, there are a few domestic issues that are reliably supported by the vast majority of evangelicals in this country. And one of them is the reduction or the elimination of abortion. And by the way, Catholics tend to poll more on the reduction of abortion. Evangelicals tend to poll more on the reduction of abortion, depending upon the state and the circumstances.

[00:49:54] And in this election, the Catholic turnout, again, with a Catholic vice president, okay, the convert to Catholicism, the Catholic turnout went down 10%, okay? You know, the whole premise of taking decisions about abortion back to the states because of overturning Roe v. Wade, which has long been a position of a lot of Republicans, wouldn't presuppose that state after state after state would all of a sudden put in their state constitution

[00:50:23] nonetheless, support of abortion up to birth, literally partial birth abortion type approaches. And the Republican Party chose to sit out the abortion conversation entirely while the Democratic Party leaned into it. And again, I'm not expressing points of view. It's just like raw, level-headed analysis of the politics. The Democrats decided to use abortion policy as a turnout mechanism.

[00:50:50] And so there were multiple, multiple constitutional amendments, multiple bills across multiple states, including in the state of Virginia. By the way, very, very cleverly, cleverly worded amendments in the state of Virginia that, you know, you had to have four PhDs and a lawyer to advise you on what they actually meant. But the net effect was they increased turnout because they didn't ignore abortion politics. Republicans decided to sit out the conversation. And it wasn't just an abortion. You know, the administration also embraced some like weird policies related to the legalization

[00:51:19] of drugs, you know, including psychedelic drugs that are just immensely, immensely unpopular policies when it comes to a lot of middle America and certainly the evangelical community. So the net effect of all of it, Tony, is that the Republican Party, on purpose or on accident, decided that, ah, we don't have to worry about evangelicals. They're going to turn out anyhow. And they didn't turn out. And they didn't turn out at a historically low level.

[00:51:46] And it resulted in the most significant blue tidal wave that we've seen really, really kind of ever, right? I mean, since Newt Gingrich was the first Republican to sort of like get the Congress back into play with four Republicans. So we just have about a minute left, Johnny. So I think lessons will be learned on two sides of this coin going forward. I think evangelicals are going to suffer under the policies that are going to be advanced under this new Congress.

[00:52:15] And so they're going to pay a price for that. And they're going to come back next time and say, you know what? We shouldn't have stayed home. So there's, I do not give an excuse to evangelicals who stayed home simply because they weren't motivated by the Republican Party. But on the other side, I have to chastise the Republican Party for not advancing the core values that they've championed for all of these years that they know is essential to their core constituency. Yeah, I mean, the unpardonable scent when it comes to politics is a lack of conviction, right?

[00:52:44] You have to have conviction on what you believe in. And we ended up in this sort of mushy middle and a perfect storm of policy confusion. And really, the moment that everyone's looking at is 2028. Like, who are going to be the candidates? And by the way, the Democratic Party has decided that they're going to have a conversation on religion. They ran five candidates who were either clergy or on their way to being clergy.

[00:53:14] And that used to not be the case. They used to ignore religion altogether. I can tell you, you know, that that it's going to be very, very hard for a Republican to win the White House in 2028. Going to be hard to get the Senate back. The House, you know, it's it's more possible. But if they just do what they just did, they're guaranteed to lose. Johnny, we've got to leave it there. Thanks for joining us, folks. Thank you for joining us as well. And until next time, remember, keep standing.

[00:53:46] Washington Watch with Tony Perkins is brought to you by Family Research Council. To support our efforts to advance faith, family and freedom, please text GIVE to 67742. That's GIVE to 67742. Portions of the show discussing candidates are brought to you by Family Research Council Action. For more information, please visit TonyPerkins.com.